A comparative market analysis, a CMA, values your home by taking recent sales of homes like yours, in your own pocket of the neighbourhood, and adjusting each sale price for every way that home differs from yours. The agent then checks the result against what is listed now and what failed to sell. The quick honesty test: every adjustment either has two sales behind it or is labelled a judgement with the reasoning written down, and the result is a dated range, not one number.
The One Check That Separates a Serious CMA From a Flattering One
I am Moe Asgarian, and I have priced homes across Toronto, North York, Willowdale, Richmond Hill, Thornhill, Markham, Vaughan, Aurora and Newmarket for more than fifteen years. What follows is what I would tell my own family before they let anyone value their house. A flattering evaluation hands you one number, usually close to the one you were hoping for, and shows you nothing behind it. A serious CMA hands you a range with a date on it, the comparable sales with their addresses, and next to every adjustment one of two things: the two sales that produce it, or the word judgement and a line of reasoning.

So ask three questions. Which adjustments are supported by a pair of sales? Which are judgement? And where does the range land if the judgement ones are taken out? An agent who can answer those has done the work. An agent who cannot has brought you a pitch.
A Worked Example, Made Up on Purpose, With No Dollar Figures
This is an illustration, not a real deal, and I have left the dollar figures out on purpose so the method is what you see. Picture a two-storey detached in Jefferson, Richmond Hill: four bedrooms, a standard lot, the original kitchen, an unfinished basement, a quiet street. Three sales are on the table. Sale A is on the same street from the same builder, with a renovated kitchen and a bigger pie-shaped lot, sold six weeks ago. Sale B is a near twin on the arterial road at the edge of the pocket, sold last month. Sale C is a bungalow two streets over on a similar lot, sold in the spring.

A is the best comp, and it gets adjusted down for the kitchen and the lot. B is the second comp, and it gets adjusted up for the road. C is dropped: a different house type and a spring sale, though its history stays in the file as a check. Now the grades. The kitchen adjustment is pair-supported if the pocket has two recent near-identical sales, one renovated and one not; the gap between them is the adjustment, and it is a tight number. The pie-lot adjustment has no clean pair in this pocket this season, so it is a judgement. It still pulls A's adjusted price down, but the band around it is wider, and the CMA says it leans on an older pair from the next pocket over.
The result is a range. The high end is A adjusted with the smaller lot discount. The low end is B adjusted with the smaller road premium. The CMA tells you which band is doing the widening, and that is the part you are entitled to question. For a condo the same logic runs in three lines. In a Willowdale tower, the same floor plate three floors down sold with parking and your unit has none, so that comp comes down, and in most towers that adjustment is pair-supported because units with and without parking trade often. A unit in the building across the street with a higher maintenance fee is a worse comp than the one in your own building.

What a CMA Reads: Four Kinds of Listings and Two Clocks
A CMA reads four kinds of listings, and you should see all four. Sold listings are the evidence. Sold-conditional listings are the freshest signal, though the price is not public until the deal firms up. Active listings are your competition, the market's reply to a price in real time. Expired and terminated listings are the ones that did not work, and they only mean something once you read their history: was the home relisted, repriced, pulled by the seller, was there a tenant, were the photos poor, was it listed in the wrong week.
That is where the two clocks matter. As of TRREB's September 2026 Market Watch, the average listing in the GTA had been on the market 34 days by the listing count and 51 days by the property count. The first, Listing Days on Market, counts the current listing only. The second, Property Days on Market, counts across relistings of the same property within the same listing arrangement, so a fresh listing under a new arrangement can show a low number again. If a CMA shows you a comp with a short listing count and no history, ask for the property count and the full listing history. Some homes do sell fast for good reasons, and I wrote about them in Why Some Toronto Condos Still Sell in Under 30 Days, but a reset clock is not one of them.

Choosing Comps: Freehold in York Region Versus a Toronto Condo
This section answers one audit question: are these the right comps, or the convenient ones? For a freehold house in Richmond Hill, Markham, Vaughan, Aurora or Newmarket, the right comp is in the same pocket, not just inside the same radius. The school boundary, the frontage and depth of the lot, a ravine or whatever the yard backs onto, bungalow versus two-storey, the age of the build, the kind of basement, and the road all matter more than distance on a map. That is why sale C was dropped above and sale B was adjusted for the road.
For a condo in Toronto, North York or Willowdale the order is fixed: your own building first, the same floor plate and exposure, the same parking and locker situation; then the sister buildings from the same developer; then across the street. A building across the road with a higher maintenance fee and a different reserve fund picture is a different product to a buyer, even if the floor plan looks alike. Once the condo range is in hand, the selling plan is in How to Sell Your Toronto Condo in a Buyer's Market.

Time and Momentum: Why the Spring Number Is Not Your Number
The rule for every adjustment is simple: adjust the comp, never your own home. If the comp is better, subtract; if it is worse, add. Time is an adjustment too, and the one most often skipped. Every sold comp carries the market of the week it was negotiated. The time adjustment comes from your pocket's own sales over the period: what similar homes there fetched in the spring against the latest closings, and what is sitting unsold now. If the pocket is quiet, the time adjustment is a judgement, labelled as one, with a wider band.
The wider market is context, not the adjustment. As of TRREB's September 2026 Market Watch, the GTA average selling price was $1,006,409, down 5.1% from a year earlier. That number never sets the adjustment for one house on one street in Thornhill or Aurora; the pocket's sales do. So check the date on the CMA, and ask how much weight the spring comp is carrying. In a rising month the same logic runs the other way: the old comp is marked up.

CMA, Bank Appraisal, Online Estimate or Tax Notice: Which One Are You Holding?
| Document | Who orders it | What it looks at | What it cannot see |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agent's CMA | You, before listing | Adjusted comparable sales, actives and expireds in your pocket | Nothing a buyer sees, if the agent walked the home |
| Lender's appraisal | The bank, after a price exists | Comparable sales, to protect the loan | What a buyer would pay above the lender's comfort |
| Online estimate | Nobody, it runs on its own | Public records and listing data | The kitchen, the reserve fund, the busy road |
| Property tax notice | The assessment system, on its own schedule | A tax figure for a fixed date | Today's market |
A CMA is the agent's opinion of what a buyer will pay today. The appraisal protects the lender's loan and is ordered after you have a price, not before. The online estimate has never been inside the unit and cannot see the kitchen, the reserve fund or the busy road. The assessed value on your property tax notice is a tax figure set on its own schedule, not today's market value. None of these is a substitute for the others.
What people actually want is the street-level number. Readers of our newsletter in Markham, North York and around Eglinton and Jane have written to us asking for the sales on their own street, and owners in Richmond Hill and across York Region are among those asking. On every home we list, we receive a weekly report of online activity, which is the first-week buyer behaviour no estimate can see. If you are choosing who prices your home, judge them by the CMA they bring; I set out the other tests in How to Choose a Real Estate Agent in Toronto.
If you want your street's sales and a written CMA with the comps and the adjustments shown, fill out the form at the bottom of this page or book a free consultation with me, Moe Asgarian. You will find more in our buying-and-selling guides. Stay well and take care.
Frequently Asked Questions
How far back do sold comparables go in a Toronto CMA?
There is no fixed rule. In a pocket with steady sales, the last few months are enough and the most recent closings carry the most weight. In a quiet pocket or a fast-moving market, an older sale can stay in as a check, but it gets a time adjustment that is labelled as a judgement and widens the range.
Is a realtor's CMA the same as a bank mortgage appraisal in Ontario?
No. A CMA is an agent's opinion of what a buyer will pay today, prepared before you list. An appraisal is ordered for the lender after a price exists, to protect the loan. They can land in different places, and neither one is the assessed value on your property tax notice.
Why can't I use my neighbour's spring sale price to value my home this fall?
Because that sale carries the market of the week it was negotiated, and the house may differ from yours in lot, condition, layout or road. A CMA adjusts it for each difference and for time, using your pocket's latest sales, and shows you the reasoning behind each adjustment.
